Alessandro Strumia, professor of theoretical physics at the University of Pisa, gave a lecture at a seminar on high-energy physics and gender at CERN, Geneva. Shortly thereafter it was announced that Mr. Strumia was suspended from all his functions at CERN. What did Mr. Strumia show and say on his 26 slides?

Well, so many people in the vastness of the Internet appeared to know a lot about it and had already formed strong opinions. I also wanted to do that, but unfortunately I could not find the slides anywhere on the CERN websites; in fact, they were deleted. In order not to be dependent on circulating fragments second or seventh hand, mixed with a lot of emotions from the Internet, I have asked Mr. Strumia by e-mail to kindly send me his slides. Within one minute(!) he replied and told me that I can find the slides attached to a blog post from well-known blogger Luboš Motl on the subject. So I went through the slides and found them really interesting; definitely there is a lot of stuff we should talk about, ideally all together as a (scientific) community.

However, this post is limited to one important question: what does it say about academia to suspend a researcher because of a talk he gave? Let’s just assume the arguments and examples he discussed were poor, crude, flawed, wrong, whatever. It should be easy to argument against those. However, among all the reactions to the incidence I found online, there wasn’t a single one that actually dealt with the content of his talk. OK, so let’s assume the opposite: he has a point in what he says and the data he showed is sound. In this case his suspension would be even more worrying and a measure that cannot possibly be favored by anyone who is ready to really delve into gender issues in science and discuss them openly.

However, I seem to be the only person in my Internet bubble who wouldn’t mind to be a part of this discourse. The fact that so many people congratulate the decision makers at CERN on this suspension causes irritation. It raises suspicion that some people out there are afraid of an open argument on the subject. Instead, for questions about gender in science, only a certain range of opinions seems to be allowed outside of which presumably Mr. Strumia has moved. With no more than expressing my consternation about this decision, I am probably also breaking the mainstreamed code of conduct in academia but hey, what the heck!

I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it", Evelyn Beatrice Hall wrote in the beginning of the last century. At the moment we seem to be as far away from that ideal as we haven't been for a long time.

Note 1: I do not know Alessandro Strumia; had never heard of him until yesterday. I have no personal interest (and no intention) to protect him.

Note 2: I express my purely personal opinion, and no institution with which I am associated need to identify with it.

Note 3: I included a link to Luboš Motl's because you can find Strumia's slides there and not because I generally agree with his views. In fact, I have the feeling he is a little bit, ahm, bitter.


0 #33 uzopuxiuvculo 2022-06-30 21:02
Alohasu: Okabisve
0 #32 ewavakiba 2022-06-30 16:05
Ileguezuv: Egaluka
0 #31 onaxepucid 2022-06-30 15:48
Aluxuy: Ejburupoh
0 #30 ubnisezo 2022-06-30 15:13
Ejuooleke: Aezewec
0 #29 iyecidmer 2022-06-15 15:53
Dadabuor: Awueye
0 #28 lgibm 2022-03-12 12:20
To do is not helpful.No, even defame a behavior was clear.Quivering swiing, a robber baron (巨刀) (曲線) gently bend the curves of the frozen geometry and of (偃月) a month with.Dosin The width of the (Radical 18 身) Chinese, two inches, is a ladle with meshes long handle length and a half.In addition, The lake, and not to protect your hands.Ungung ....... at the minute she cause to the knife.
0 #27 betgoca 2022-03-12 08:07
The tapping sound. Perhaps if it were not for the West, if it was next to a table where several people sat and discussed, Yoo Baek-dang would have risen from the chair and continued his words while spinning. Ko So-wol glanced at him. It was also an uncomfortable attitude to sit with my legs fluttering, but the words were bursting out in time. "It's a huge amount of money that can be said to be the entire property of generations."
0 #26 betgoca 2022-03-12 04:37
Add a movement. On top of that, the name of the Gwangpungdan was all about this simple method. Quite naturally, they were movements that could be thought of with knives, and complex and mysterious changes were a method that could not be seen with the eyes turned upside down. The wood-burning chamber, which was pushed back here, was out of breath, angry, and boiled up, and how could he do this simple thing?
0 #25 savewcal 2022-03-11 08:55
A man's debt.Never even met I had never before and know only has only a rumor that the heavens and one defeat..Heavens and one defeat. rumors about the wind also mungninyeong eurobakke will not be heard.Nevertheless, he gave me!Hyeongnyeoncho was rough do-rags and head wounds.Now only effectively established the the wind.It has already been his minions.
0 #24 betgoca 2022-03-11 04:20
When I asked the Luits, Hilato Racers, Luon Rubain... In addition, "many people" said they found three royal girls. So I told him that there was nothing to worry about, to leave with confidence. But, why, is there no one who says 'leaves' in a wagon? There are people who are looking for it, and there is no one who went back...

Add comment

Security code